Monday, January 12, 2009

The Social Consequences of Individual Choice

Recent disasters in the world-wide financial system have highlighted the fact that free markets (i.e., markets with minimal regulation) are unstable and by themselves neglect important social concerns.

Benjamin R. Barber in Jihad vs. McWorld gives a rather succinct example that makes this point in a very clear way:

When I choose to buy a car, I choose to get from here to there efficiently and perhaps pleasantly; however, among the consequences of my choice may be air pollution, resource depletion, the disadvantaging of public transportation, pressure on hospital facilities, and the despoilation of the natural environment by a highway system.  As a consumer, the only way I can avoid these consequences is to refuse to buy a car -- an irrational act from the narrow economic perspective and one that throws a wrench into the market economy.  So I play the consumer and buy the car.  Capitalism is served and so am I -- as a consumer.  But in a democratic society, I am not just a consumer, I am a citizen.  And as a citizen, I can act in common with others to modify the untoward public consequences of my private choice.  As a citizen, I can join with others and redress the ill effects of my car purchase: we can outlaw leaded gas, fund electric engine research, subsidize public transportation, mandate hospital insurance for drivers, and limit highway construction in scenic regions.  These civic activities do not curb our market freedom, they facilitate it.  Democracy makes markets work by allowing us the freedom of our consumer choices in the knowledge that we can counteract their accompanying vices.  To do so, however, we must have alternative nonmarket institutions, and in the international arena such democratic tools are entirely absent.

The key point is in the last sentence, which I will augment slightly --  there must be alternative institutions that have the mandate and the resources to contain and control the excesses of free markets.  Such institutions are not inimical to free markets.  Rather, they preserve the long term viability of free markets that otherwise eventually would implode.

Thursday, March 27, 2008

What makes a great presidential candidate

Does Hillary still have a chance?  Currently, she will need to win two thirds of the delegates in the states that have not yet voted.  This will be very difficult for her to accomplish.  Yet hope remains that she can persuade some large proportion of super delegates that she is the only candidate that can win.

Given the broad appeal and  leadership qualities that Obama already has demonstrated, this is going to be close to impossible.  She must be hoping that some huge character flaw of his will be brought to light.  Despite Hillary's own personal strengths and the issues on which she has demonstrated she will choose and strongly support those who truly need help, she hasn't inspired us in the way Obama has.

Leadership is more than making the right policy decisions, more than strongly pushing to make those policy decisions work, more than being a smart person with great experience in and knowledge of public affairs.  Leadership, almost by definition, is the ability to get other people to work together to accomplish something important.  I don't have the definitive answer to what makes a great leader, but I'm pretty sure it has to do with raising hopes, raising confidence, raising awareness, and making people feel that they want to do something, whatever that something is.   They have to have confidence, too, that the outcome will be what they want.

The great leader can get right into your head and become something like the conscience that your parents and grandparents planted there.  His/her words and urgings sit there in your conscience, ringing some kind of chord that has its roots in what you believe is right and just.  Because it works at this very fundamental level, it is a powerful force.